Explore the New York Pizzeria menu featuring thin-crust pizzas, hot and cold subs, gluten-free choices, and flavorful wings. Family-owned with fast service and allergy-friendly care at 83 E Main St, Gouverneur, NY.
New York Pizzeria, nestled at 83 E Main St in Gouverneur, NY, offers a welcoming slice of authentic New York-style pizza with a warm, family-owned vibe. This pizzeria truly understands how to craft a satisfying meal that caters to a variety of tastes and dietary needs, making it a standout in the North Country pizza scene.
The menu is anchored by classic favorites like the Large Pepperoni Pizza and the Chicken Parm Pizza, both shining examples of well-balanced flavor and fresh ingredients. The crust strikes a perfect note—thin yet sturdy enough to hold generous toppings without losing that signature New York chew. The sauce is rich and tangy, blending seamlessly with their high-quality cheeses. One devoted fan, Nate Bloxham, praises the thin crust and exquisite sauce, calling it the best pizza in the region.
Specialty pizzas like the Small Breakfast Pizza, topped with eggs, cheese, ham, and bacon, showcase creative twists that bring hearty comfort to the table. For those with gluten sensitivities, New York Pizzeria goes above and beyond. Sydney Grosso’s glowing account highlights the kitchen’s careful attention to preventing cross-contamination with dedicated gluten-free preparation areas and separate fryers for items like wings, ensuring a safe and delicious experience for all.
The Chicken Wings and Mozzarella Sticks are well-worth mentioning. The wings, especially the garlic variety, come tender and flavorful, with a buttery dip that elevates the dish. Many customers enjoy pairing their meal with refreshing beverages—choices range from Pink Lemonade and Shirley Temple to classic sodas like Dr Pepper and Mountain Dew, available by the glass or in pitchers, perfect for sharing.
Not every experience has been flawless. Katherine Sosebee’s feedback points to some service hiccups during a busy takeout order, reminding us that even the best places face challenges with consistency during peak times. Yet, the pizzeria’s quick and convenient pickup service, especially on busy nights, has won applause, as noted by Erin Weldon who called it “the best pizza I’ve had in a long time.”
Overall, New York Pizzeria’s menu offers something for everyone—from personal XS pizzas to large, customizable hand-tossed options and specialty pies. Their commitment to accommodating dietary restrictions, delivering hearty portions, and maintaining quality makes it a culinary gem worth visiting. This is comfort food done right, with an edge of genuine care that makes every meal feel like home.
